By CHRIS TOMLINSON, Associated Press Writer
Monday December 3 5:57 PM ET
KAMA ADO, Afghanistan - Children's shoes, bits of charred carpet and cooking
pots litter what is left of this hamlet,
along with dead cows and sheep. Here and there are craters, some 20 feet
wide. One holds the tail fin from a Mk83
1,000-pound bomb.
The United States says it is targeting Osama bin Laden's followers around
this village in northeastern Afghanistan. But
anti-Taliban leaders say local villagers, not terrorists, are dying in
the raids because Americans are using faulty intelligence.
On Monday provincial officials brought reporters to see what they said
was the destruction done by U.S. bombs at Kama
Ado, about a half-hour walk along a trail from the nearest town.
Witnesses and survivors say U.S. warplanes dropped more than 25 bombs in
four passes over the village on Saturday.
One resident, Kamal Huddin, said 155 of the 300 residents were killed.
``We were farmers. We were poor people. And we didn't have any contact
with any organizations,'' Huddin said. His
dust-covered face was streaked with tears as he dug out his few remaining
possessions - a few clothes and a wooden
plow.
In Washington, Pentagon spokesman Rear Adm. John Stufflebeem told reporters
he had seen no evidence to support
reports of U.S. bombs striking civilian villages in the area.
``We have heard anecdotal reports that this is an area where Osama bin
Laden has been using some of his wealth to buy
local village chieftains' support,'' Stufflebeem said.
Mohammed Zeman, the provincial anti-Taliban defense chief, says up to 1,200
non-Afghan fighters may be hiding in the
White Mountains, specifically in cave complexes near Tora Bora and Mawal,
more than six miles from Kama Ado.
But Zeman insisted that his men control the Kama Ado area, that the village
elders have pledged their support in fighting
the Taliban and al-Qaida.
He also said anti-Taliban fighters have been among the bombing victims
and showed reporters the bodies of seven of his
men.
``These are my villagers. I sent them the day before yesterday to provide
security in the town, and now they are dead,''
Zeman said. He said he had asked U.S. authorities to stop the attacks,
but had received no response.
If bin Laden money was funneled to Kama Ado, there was little to show for
it in what's left of the village of about 30
simple mud homes with straw roofs.
Unlike other Taliban and al-Qaida bases, there were no documents, no heavy
weapons, no ammunition boxes, just three
rocket-propelled grenades in one of the homes. Such weapons are common
in Afghanistan and every village has a few to
protect it in the absence of a police force.
Residents, who had spent their entire lives farming terraced fields irrigated
with melting snow from the White Mountains,
claimed fighters from the Taliban and al-Qaida had never even visited them.
Huddin said he and men from neighboring villages dug 44 graves Sunday,
each marked with timber scavenged from the
wreckage.
``We put as many as four to five bodies in each grave. But most of it was
just pieces of bodies. We filled the graves up
with those pieces,'' Huddin said.
Coalition spokesman Kenton Keith said military pilots who dropped bombs
in the area ``think they hit their targets,'' but
added coalition officials were checking the reports of civilians killed.
``We do have an overriding imperative ... and that is to root out international
terrorism,'' he said Monday in Islamabad,
Pakistan. ``We do not deliberately target civilians ... and al-Qaida did
deliberately target civilians on Sept. 11.''
Zeman said bombing late Sunday in the nearby village of Agom killed seven anti-Taliban fighters and five civilians.
The attack followed another on the same village earlier Sunday that destroyed
an anti-Taliban headquarters and killed eight
people, Zeman said. Dozens of people have been treated at a hospital in
Jalalabad.
The coalition launched attacks on the Taliban on Oct. 7 after they refused
to turn over bin Laden, the prime suspect in the
terrorist attacks in the United States. Zeman and Ali both say they support
U.S. airstrikes, but only in the mountains.
Men and boys near Kama Ado watched Monday morning as an American B-52 bomber
streaked across the sky and
plumes of black smoke rose from the White Mountains. Malik Nazeer, a tribal
elder, said that was where the bombs
should fall, not on his people's villages.
Nazeer said he understood the fight against terrorism, but said his people
were now suffering for no other reason than that
they live in Afghanistan.
``We were unhappy about the people who were killed on Sept. 11. They were
killed by terrorists. But now we are dying,''
Nazeer said. ``Why don't Americans recognize that?''
Villages pay price as US bombs go awry
By Philip Smucker in Jalalabad
The Telegraph (UK)
December 4, 2001
SCORES of villagers have been killed by off-target American bombing of
Tora Bora, Osama bin Laden's suspected
mountain hideout, a senior anti-Taliban commander said yesterday.
Last night, as the barrage continued, explosions could be heard from the
outskirts of the eastern Afghan city of Jalalabad,
to the north of Tora Bora. Villagers said bombs had missed the target and
landed in their impoverished communities a few
miles from the cave complex.
Injured Afghans last night packed the emergency wards of Jalalabad's main
hospital as relatives, some of whom said they
had lost dozens of members of their extended families, denounced the bombings
as grossly off-target.
Haji Zaman Ghamsharik, the regional military commander, said bin Laden
was sighted in the area three days ago and had
been sent a message appealing for negotiations to end the bloodshed.
He said bin Laden was asked to consider the hardship he was bringing to
the Afghan people as American aircraft bombed
the area. Almost 100 civilians had died over the past three days of raids,
he added.
Hazrat Ali, the provincial security chief, said two elders claimed to have
received a message from bin Laden in which he
said he did not want to fight fellow Muslims, only "foreign troops".
Mr Ali said he had sent a delegation to the White Mountains to negotiate
the surrender of the foreign fighters defending bin
Laden's mountain base. If they do not comply, he said, they would come
under attack from a force of 1,500 troops sent
from Jalalabad within days.
Kenton Keith, the spokesman for the US-led coalition, said reports of civilian
casualties around Tora Bora were being
checked but he could not confirm whether any American bombs had gone astray
and accused the Taliban of using "human
shields".
Moor Mohamed was still conscious even as doctors said they doubted he would
survive. Both of his mangled arms had
been amputated. "How can the Americans be so blind?" said Sultan Mohamed,
the boy's uncle. "Everyone says Osama is
seven miles deep inside Tora Bora in a cave; nowhere near our village."
The strikes on his home were carried out with large "dumb bombs" that blew
giant craters in the earth and levelled the mud
brick houses at the base of the White Mountains. Dozens of men, women and
children were reported to have been buried.
"At 2.30am we heard a huge noise of something hitting our village," said
Sultan Mohamed. "It was a giant bomb but it just
hit with a thud and did not explode. The second one hit nearby and the
third one hit our roof. Moor was sleeping and it
took us two hours to pry him free from the rubble. I'm afraid it was too
late."
In the same ward, 14 other men and boys were critically injured. A room
down the hall for females included still younger
children, who had been injured in the blast while sleeping.
Over two days, three villages were hit, all of them at the base of Tora
Bora, but apparently far down the road from the
Arab guerrillas of bin Laden's al-Qa'eda organisation. Dick Cheney, the
US vice president, last week said he believed that
bin Laden was hiding in the vast Tora Bora cave network. British defence
sources said they had similar intelligence.
The US strikes appeared widely off-target. At least 15 fighters and administrators
working with a Western-backed
warlord in Jalalabad were killed in bombing. Cdr Ghamsharik had boasted
of meeting US representatives in Jalalabad last
week.
Lala Agha, a villager, said he had helped to place 22 bodies in lorries
and driven them to a burial ground: "I was in a house
when the bombs hit and we raced outside digging for bodies. I think there
are still dozens buried in the earth."
The young man said some of his fellow villagers were now angry at the commander.
"They say that Haji Zaman told the
Americans to bomb," he said.
At the main hospital in Jalalabad most of the families of the injured and
dying blamed the US military. They said they
understood that the Americans had been targeting bin Laden, but questioned
how "smart bomb" strikes could have gone
so far afield. Niaz Mohamad, 45, said: "The US says that they can see everything.
Why don't they hit Osama and not us?"
Some of the villagers vehemently denied that there were any Arabs living
in their area. Three weeks ago, a convoy of
several hundred Arabs are said to have left their vehicles on the road
into Tora Bora.
A 60-year-old man who lost his wife and two grandsons said he escaped because
he had left home for the evening prayer.
"The Americans are shouting that they will bring peace, but they can't
find Osama and instead they bomb us."